Season 9.1: Best Episode Tournament: SpongeBob You're Fired vs. Eek, an Urchin!

[Guest hilaryfan80]

It's now time for Match J of Round 2. Squid Plus One crushed Squid Defense, so that has moved on to Round 3. Now, here's Match J...

ROUND 2

VS.

Jjs' prediction:

Okay, I think we all know Eek, An Urchin is going to win. But first I want to say a few things on SpongeBob, You're Fired. I absolutely hate it. I wish it didn't get to move onto Round 2 automatically. I think the episode is a terrible idea, and as a result, is nothing. It's boring, padded out, and has the worst setup, ever. I hated it when it first premiered and still do to this day. I won't chastise anybody if they vote for it, but I just can't stand it. 

Now, have fun voting, and once again, everyone is welcome to give their thoughts here on both episodes. 

[Sweat]

To sum it up, SpongeBob You're Fired is probably my least favorite episode ever, and Eek an Urchin is one of my favorite post-movie episodes.

[WhoBibbles]

I have nothing to say about that, really

[Katniss]

Eek, an Urchin is a fun ep, while SYF is dreadfully boring. There's a clear winner here IMO.

[So Sejima]

...........moving on.

[Minty Car]

Eww, SYF is just awful

[SpongeOddFan]

Ew SYF

EAU  gets my vote, that's all i have to say, really.

[illiniguy34]

"Eek, An Urchin" has grown on me and I think it's alright now. "Spongebob, You're Fired", oh dear God.

[Less_SpongeBob]

1 hour ago, Halibut said:

To sum it up, SpongeBob You're Fired is probably my least favorite episode ever, and Eek an Urchin is one of my favorite post-movie episodes.

This

[mae2941]

Nothing to say to explain my choice

[Cha]

Long stories, short.

Whenever Plankton is put in a setting where he's not trying to acquire the formula is great enough. I just loved the team work between him and the KK employees. And Plankton in disguise as female urchin being attacked by hundreds of the others was both very twisted and hilarious. This has to be my second  (or maybe even most if I took the time to rewatch it again) favorite s9 episode. 

Whereas SBYF has the decency to have SB genuinely feeling depressed out of his wits (with an awesome Best Day Ever mug) and getting a new job. However it was A LOT of crying filler between the beginning and especially when he was on a job hunt. 

[mae2941]

42 minutes ago, Cha said:

Long stories, short.

Whenever Plankton is put in a setting where he's not trying to acquire the formula is great enough. I just loved the team work between him and the KK employees. And Plankton in disguise as female urchin being attacked by hundreds of the others was both very twisted and hilarious. This has to be my second  (or maybe even most if I took the time to rewatch it again) favorite s9 episode. 

Whereas SBYF has the decency to have SB genuinely feeling depressed out of his wits (with an awesome Best Day Ever mug) and getting a new job. However it was A LOT of crying filler between the beginning and especially when he was on a job hunt. 

About the sentence in bold, weird since it's the only reason this episode is an atrocity for Mr. Exit. C'mon, that's stupid to dislike it because of that.

So far, no one voted for SBYF, I almost feel sorry for that episode

Edited November 16, 2015 by MrTortellini00

[Jjs Goodman]

Well, SpongeBob, You're Fired lost embarrassingly, as it received 0 votes. Ouch. Eek, An Urchin! has moved on.

Stay tuned for the next thread for Match K.

[Guest hilaryfan80]

Filler