Season 9.1: Best Episode Tournament: Eek, an Urchin! vs. Evil Spatula

[Guest hilaryfan80]

It's now time for Match B of Round 1! Since Squid Baby pretty much had zero chance whatsoever in the previous round (sorry Cha, but at least we have an opinion of dissent ), I decided to move onto Match B early since 18-1 is a pretty decisive decision. Squid Defense has moved on and will face Squid Plus One in Match I for Round 2. I'm planning to do this daily, so hopefully we can keep getting the same amount of votes. Now, here's Match B...

ROUND 1

VS.

Winner faces: SpongeBob, You're Fired in Round 2

Jjs' prediction:

Eek, An Urchin! I know was beloved by most people, so I'm pretty positive that will win this match. It is also my personal vote, as I still find it a pretty funny episode. Evil Spatula is okay, but slightly forgettable. I don't think Evil Spatula has much of a chance unless it has some secret fan club I never heard of, but who knows.

Now, have fun voting, and once again, everyone is welcome to give their thoughts here on both episodes.

[Katniss]

Eek, an Urchin is pretty funny so it's got my vote.

[Cha]

Eek An Urchin is the best episode of 9 besides License to Milkshake, hands down. 

[Nosferatu!]

Eek, An Urchin! for me.  

prettysureyouknowwhy

[So Sejima]

Evil Spatula has a bit more replay value to me honestly, both are good episodes but that's what pushes ES a bit farther to me.

[illiniguy34]

I've only seen "Eek, an Urchin", soooooooo.......

[WhoBibbles]

I really liked Evil Spatula but it was nowhere near as hilarious as Eek an Uchin, so Eek an Urchin gets my vote.

[mae2941]

I choose Eek, an Urchin. They're both good imo, but I think Eek an Urchin is funnier. At least people here like it despite that rape scene Mr. Enter makes a big deal about. Strange that my most recently seen episodes got paired together

8 hours ago, Cha said:

Eek An Urchin is the best episode of 9 besides License to Milkshake, hands down. 

I thought I was the only one to really like License to Milshake lol

Edited November 8, 2015 by MrTortellini00

[Inanimate Carbon Rod]

"Eek! An Urchin!" gets my vote.

[Less_SpongeBob]

On one half, you got the season's most fast-paced and fun episode, and on the other you got the best realization of mistake the show's done.

Tough one, but I'll pick the former.

[Jjs Goodman]

Yet another decisive vote. Eek, An Urchin! will move on and face SpongeBob, You're Fired in Match J for Round 2.

Check out the next thread for Match C.

[Guest hilaryfan80]

Filler