Season 9.1: Best Episode Tournament: Squid Plus One vs. Squid Defense

[Guest hilaryfan80]

It's now time for Match I, which is the first match of Round 2! Squirrel Record narrowly beat Bumper to Bumper, so Squirrel Record has moved on and will face License to Milkshake in Match P for Round 2. We now begin Round 2. Now, here's Match I...

ROUND 2

VS.

Jjs' prediction:

Once again, two Squidward centric episodes face off against each other. Squid Defense pretty much had an automatic win last time due to the episode it was against, but this time I think it's time is up. I am pretty sure Squid Plus One will get this one. Squid Defense just still doesn't work for me, while Squid Plus One is much more well-executed.

 

Now, have fun voting, and once again, everyone is welcome to give their thoughts here on both episodes. 

[WhoBibbles]

I like Squid Defense but Squid Plus One is more well-written and the best Squidward-centrered episode of the season.

[Sweat]

Yeah, Squid Defense is one of the more garb episodes of the season so far, especially the pretty unanimously disliked ending. Squid Plus One is yet another masterpiece of a near-consistently great new era in the show.

[JCM]

Squid Plus One because Norton.

[So Sejima]

Squid Plus One had pacing issues and a bizarre af ending...yet then again this is Squid Defense.

[mae2941]

I liked Squid Plus One: it has some problems but not as much as Squid Defense, so it gets my vote

[illiniguy34]

I loved "Squid Plus One". 

[So Sejima]

There's always one person. :p

[Jjs Goodman]

Squid Plus One wins, and has moved on.

Check out the next thread for Match J.

[Guest hilaryfan80]

Filler