[Barnacle Boy's Anecdote]

On 7/25/2019 at 8:19 AM, Wintermelon43 said:

Which between Plankton and Krabs do you think is a bit more likely and why?

Potentially Krabs, as weird as it sounds. Perhaps he had a personal reason to get that cake away from the party...

[Barnacle Boy's Anecdote]

Oh, excuse Mermaid Man, he clearly wasn't paying attention. It seems obvious to me at this point that Plankton or Krabs stole SpongeKid's cake.

[Barnacle Boy's Anecdote]

On 12/21/2017 at 6:47 PM, SnOWMan said:

By old coot, do you mean Old Man Jenkins or Mermaid Man?

Since you and Mermaid Man didn't get drunk, what did you see happen after everyone else did?

 

Jenkins. Mermaid Man may be silly, but he'd never do a thing like this.

It's a vague blue. I saw a flash of light from some contraption, but couldn't tell who was holding it.

On 12/21/2017 at 8:32 PM, NegiSantie said:

Did you eat a cucumber sandwich?

No.

[Barnacle Boy's Anecdote]

Yeah yeah, I was invited to this party with the old coot. Then some evildoer spiked the egg nog, you know by now. Thanks to our powers however, we did not get drunk, but I did feel a bit off.

I got a nice present from the Squilliam guy: an actual pair of shoes. But I forgot where I placed them. I think I left them in an episode where I appeared.

As for who did it...maybe that other old coot. They’re always the last person you’d suspect...